RDR2 OT **Mark Spoilers**

[DynamiteCop 2,085]

1 minute ago, madmaltese said:

That's the definition of a Rape Hut if ever I saw one 

 

 

Keen 

These guys are going to lose their shit lol, I was in shock, I felt violated 

[Twinblade★ 3,893]

That is pretty crazy  Before I head there i need to know, does the dude rob you of any money or items?

[DynamiteCop 2,085]

Just now, Twinblade said:

That is pretty crazy  Before I head there i need to know, does the dude rob you of any money or items?

Not that I was aware of, just save right before the spot and turn off autosaving if you're worried.

[Vini 430]

1 minute ago, Twinblade said:

That is pretty crazy  Before I head there i need to know, does the dude rob you of any money or items?

No he's not a savage cmon now

[madmaltese★ 2,554]

2 minutes ago, Twinblade said:

That is pretty crazy  Before I head there i need to know, does the dude rob you of any money or items?

Only your dignity

[Vini 430]

Decided to pay him a visit

 

 

 

 

[DynamiteCop 2,085]

6 minutes ago, Vini said:

Decided to pay him a visit

 

 

 

 

:/

 

Ahh, I thought you were gonna let him do it lol. 

[Vini 430]

31 minutes ago, DynamiteCop! said:

:/

 

Ahh, I thought you were gonna let him do it lol. 

 

My bad this time I let him do it

 

 

[DynamiteCop 2,085]

18 minutes ago, Vini said:

 

My bad this time I let him do it

 

 

lmao you fucking dick 

[Alphonse★ 453]

 

[DynamiteCop 2,085]

5 minutes ago, Alphonse said:

 

lol

[jehurey 3,228]

There was already a video online of people finding a Klan initiation meeting, and fire burning. But I allowed the full scene to play out to its intended conclusion, and it was pretty funny.

 

I took it a step further and went ahead and took care of these 19th century Incels

 

Also, did you guys find the first clue for the serial killer? Its on the path from Valentine to the camp, maybe it only appears at night.

 

[Vini 430]

Arthur's interaction with John Marston is great  

 

 

 

[madmaltese★ 2,554]

Semi long story/experience.

 

So I was riding along exploring the south of the map when I hear yelling and arguing coming from a homestead (not a stranger mission or anything). I stop to investigate and quietly enter the house and see/hear a drunk father arguing with his son about money and the son pulling his weight. The son arguing back saying the father would just drink or gamble it away and that's why mum left. The father is about the strike the son but the son walk off, out of the room right where I was standing (in the hallway). Instantly he gets a shock and the starts yelling to his dad that someone is in the house. The drunk father comes running, telling his son to hide in his room and starts yelling and threatening at me and I sort of ignored him seeing where it's gonna go but things quickly escalated and he pulls a gun on me and starts firing so I obviously fire back and kill him. Now the son in the other room hears the shots and starts screaming and crying, 'Nooo Pa, no', and real proper fear crying, I felt bad but thought since I had come this far I may as well loot the place and get something out of all this. I investigate and find a letter to the son from his mother and as I enter the room where the son is he is inconsolable, saying 'Why? Why would you do this', 'Pa, oh pa' and 'Just take what you want and leave, pleasseee', etc. So I see a cigarette card on his desk and pick it up and his cries escalate even further, 'Please, please dont take that, my mother left me it, it's all I got, please' and in that moment I felt so much like shit and the guilt had built up in me so much that I couldn't handle what just happened to this boy and what I did so I reloaded a previous save. 

 

The point of all that is that I have never felt this while playing a game. Happy, Sadness, etc, sure. But actual guilt for actions that I chose? Never. Cause it's just a game... and yet. The sequence of events, the fact it was just from my exploring, my actions to stop, intervene then panic and act as I did and most importantly just how well that story of that family was crafted from conversation and environments. Not to mention the voice acting and just how natural all of it felt and sounded to the events that unfolded, from the arguing to the shock of a home invader to the shooting. It was unbelievable. The game might have it's short comings but moments like these are unparalleled. 

 

I have other smaller and some even funny experiences but that was the highlight of the game for me so far. 

 

 

[-GD-X★ 7,729]

Lol at the pervert vids. I may just get it with that b2g1 deal. 

[Vini 430]

 

6 hours ago, madmaltese said:

Semi long story/experience.

 

So I was riding along exploring the south of the map when I hear yelling and arguing coming from a homestead (not a stranger mission or anything). I stop to investigate and quietly enter the house and see/hear a drunk father arguing with his son about money and the son pulling his weight. The son arguing back saying the father would just drink or gamble it away and that's why mum left. The father is about the strike the son but the son walk off, out of the room right where I was standing (in the hallway). Instantly he gets a shock and the starts yelling to his dad that someone is in the house. The drunk father comes running, telling his son to hide in his room and starts yelling and threatening at me and I sort of ignored him seeing where it's gonna go but things quickly escalated and he pulls a gun on me and starts firing so I obviously fire back and kill him. Now the son in the other room hears the shots and starts screaming and crying, 'Nooo Pa, no', and real proper fear crying, I felt bad but thought since I had come this far I may as well loot the place and get something out of all this. I investigate and find a letter to the son from his mother and as I enter the room where the son is he is inconsolable, saying 'Why? Why would you do this', 'Pa, oh pa' and 'Just take what you want and leave, pleasseee', etc. So I see a cigarette card on his desk and pick it up and his cries escalate even further, 'Please, please dont take that, my mother left me it, it's all I got, please' and in that moment I felt so much like shit and the guilt had built up in me so much that I couldn't handle what just happened to this boy and what I did so I reloaded a previous save. 

 

The point of all that is that I have never felt this while playing a game. Happy, Sadness, etc, sure. But actual guilt for actions that I chose? Never. Cause it's just a game... and yet. The sequence of events, the fact it was just from my exploring, my actions to stop, intervene then panic and act as I did and most importantly just how well that story of that family was crafted from conversation and environments. Not to mention the voice acting and just how natural all of it felt and sounded to the events that unfolded, from the arguing to the shock of a home invader to the shooting. It was unbelievable. The game might have it's short comings but moments like these are unparalleled. 

 

I have other smaller and some even funny experiences but that was the highlight of the game for me so far. 

 

 

 

Yea the game's on another level I can't even understand how so many outcomes were scripted in any given random encounter

 

 

Edited November 3, 2018 by Vini

[jehurey 3,228]

8 hours ago, madmaltese said:

Semi long story/experience.

 

So I was riding along exploring the south of the map when I hear yelling and arguing coming from a homestead (not a stranger mission or anything). I stop to investigate and quietly enter the house and see/hear a drunk father arguing with his son about money and the son pulling his weight. The son arguing back saying the father would just drink or gamble it away and that's why mum left. The father is about the strike the son but the son walk off, out of the room right where I was standing (in the hallway). Instantly he gets a shock and the starts yelling to his dad that someone is in the house. The drunk father comes running, telling his son to hide in his room and starts yelling and threatening at me and I sort of ignored him seeing where it's gonna go but things quickly escalated and he pulls a gun on me and starts firing so I obviously fire back and kill him. Now the son in the other room hears the shots and starts screaming and crying, 'Nooo Pa, no', and real proper fear crying, I felt bad but thought since I had come this far I may as well loot the place and get something out of all this. I investigate and find a letter to the son from his mother and as I enter the room where the son is he is inconsolable, saying 'Why? Why would you do this', 'Pa, oh pa' and 'Just take what you want and leave, pleasseee', etc. So I see a cigarette card on his desk and pick it up and his cries escalate even further, 'Please, please dont take that, my mother left me it, it's all I got, please' and in that moment I felt so much like shit and the guilt had built up in me so much that I couldn't handle what just happened to this boy and what I did so I reloaded a previous save. 

 

The point of all that is that I have never felt this while playing a game. Happy, Sadness, etc, sure. But actual guilt for actions that I chose? Never. Cause it's just a game... and yet. The sequence of events, the fact it was just from my exploring, my actions to stop, intervene then panic and act as I did and most importantly just how well that story of that family was crafted from conversation and environments. Not to mention the voice acting and just how natural all of it felt and sounded to the events that unfolded, from the arguing to the shock of a home invader to the shooting. It was unbelievable. The game might have it's short comings but moments like these are unparalleled. 

 

I have other smaller and some even funny experiences but that was the highlight of the game for me so far. 

 

 

So, I'm trying to think about what this classifies as, in terms of game development.

 

You walked in on an interactive cutscene. But it had A.I. in what the characters were going to do, and they coordinated their NPC A.I. with their voice acting.

 

And Arthur would have had specific voice acting for that scene (had you chosen to speak to them while it was happening).

 

Technically, all you did was walking into a house, shoot somebody, and then loot it. Because you walked into a small area, the developer knows what you may or may not do, and so they develop the interactive cutscene around that.  I wonder what the dad would say if you busted in there and shot the son, and then tried taking the cigarette card.

 

Too bad they don't have F5 and F9 Quick Save and Quick Load like a PC game, because I would spend 30 minutes running through the sequence again and again.

[102020393023445948594 2,223]

this is the best game ever made, no joke

 

the immersion i feel in this is insane. God of War 2018 production value in an open world game

 

R* are fucking gods  

[Hot Sauce 2,727]

I can't even bring myself to keep playing it's so dull.

[Twinblade★ 3,893]

19 minutes ago, Hot Sauce said:

I can't even bring myself to keep playing it's so dull.

I like it but I just reached chapter 3 and the story hasn’t really gone anywhere yet. I’m hoping it picks up soon and the mission design also improves.