Jump to content

Open Club  ·  22 members  ·  Rules

All Things Politics

What would happen if all the police were to leave Portland?


Recommended Posts

Would the protesting stop? 

Would it become a peaceful utopia?

 

Or would it become a crime ridden cesspool?  

 

:wonder:

 

Serious discussion. I'm trying to understand the end game of ACAB BLM ANTIFA Wall of Moms etc etc

Edited by Cooke (not admin cant help
Link to post
Share on other sites
32 minutes ago, Twinblade said:

Theres a clear correlation between less officers on the street/less funding for police and more rampant crime. Its crazy that people are actually delusional enough to pretend thats not the case.

 

17 minutes ago, Cooke (not admin cant help said:

Why is it stupid? It's what antifa wants. 

Lol stay scared boys. Tim Pool and Ben Shapiro will tell you how to think. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, Liquid said:

 

Lol stay scared boys. Tim Pool and Ben Shapiro will tell you how to think. 

mmmk. Police are a socialist thing anyway.. Might as well get rid of it and have everyone either carry guns or hire private security :whipit:

Link to post
Share on other sites
51 minutes ago, Liquid said:

 

Lol stay scared boys. Tim Pool and Ben Shapiro will tell you how to think. 

Quote

 


 

Minneapolis police are down 10% of the force since the killing of George Floyd  
Homicides, shootings and robberies have all increased dramatically in the city   
Police have told residents 'be prepared to give up your cellphone' to stay safe 

 
 

 

 

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8587211/Minneapolis-police-struggle-cope-surge-violent-crime-death-George-Floyd.html

 

Quote

 


 

New York City surpassed the gun shootings total for 2019 on Saturday night
By Saturday night there were 777 shootings so far this year, while in the whole of 2019 the city recorded 776 shootings

 
 

 

 

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8585265/New-York-City-shootings-2020-2019-man-777th-victim.html

 

There are stories like these on a near daily basis, showing increases in crime in places that are butchering their police forces. Why choose to remain ignorant? And hopefully you don't feel the urge to complain about dailymail, they're just collecting and reporting on the statistics that are already out there.

Link to post
Share on other sites
19 hours ago, Cooke (not admin cant help said:

mmmk. Police are a socialist thing anyway.. Might as well get rid of it and have everyone either carry guns or hire private security :whipit:

Orrrrr, Cities can reroute funding to help police deal with situations that they're not generally prepared for like responding to psychologically distressed individuals or disruptive minors?  That would work out better for civilians and the police than tanks and grenade launchers. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, Liquid said:

Orrrrr, Cities can reroute funding to help police deal with situations that they're not generally prepared for like responding to psychologically distressed individuals or disruptive minors?  That would work out better for civilians and the police than tanks and grenade launchers. 

 

Every cop in this country would agree that mentally ill people would be better handled by the communities. What's your point? 

 

Edited by Vini
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Vini said:

 

Every cop in this country would agree that mentally ill people would be better handled by the communities. What's your point? 

 

My point is the point. Defunding police means restructuring resources so instead of gear and more poorly trained officers there is an system in place that can offer appropriate responses.

 

An emotionally disturbed middle schooler doesn't need a cop whose only tool kit is physical force or someone having a bipolar episode doesn't get shot because they are not responding to arrest procedures. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

It would be an absolute disaster.

 

The problem is not police. The problem is how they are trained and the lack of mental health workers being integrated with first responders.

 

When you look at how many cases of death, or even just 911 calls that are related to mental breakdowns or issues, what we need is a new kind of police. A better police. NOT a wishy washy 'lets defund all police man' which would be an absolute disaster. 

 

I feel bad for police who think they are doing good for the community but are ill trained for the problems they faced, are militarized, and are then told they are not actually helping people.

Link to post
Share on other sites
28 minutes ago, Chairman_Meow said:

It would be an absolute disaster.

 

The problem is not police. The problem is how they are trained and the lack of mental health workers being integrated with first responders.

 

When you look at how many cases of death, or even just 911 calls that are related to mental breakdowns or issues, what we need is a new kind of police. A better police. NOT a wishy washy 'lets defund all police man' which would be an absolute disaster. 

 

I feel bad for police who think they are doing good for the community but are ill trained for the problems they faced, are militarized, and are then told they are not actually helping people.

The problem is America is a violent culture.  It's not just police, it's everyday citizens. More people are murdered in Chicago every month than police kill in a decade. No one seems to give a fuck about the root causes. 

Edited by Cooke (not admin cant help
Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, Cooke (not admin cant help said:

The problem is America is a violent culture.  It's not just police, it's everyday citizens. More people are murdered in Chicago every month than police kill in a decade. No one seems to give a fuck about the root causes. 

Yes, I agree.

 

When I saw reporting on flooding in the US many years ago I was blown away to see basically gangs on boats with guns use it as an opportunity to steal. I was also blown away at how much violence and rape occurred in a stadium that was used to house people who no longer had access to their homes. I don't want to dismiss the possibility that this was just terrible news reporting, it also showcased the everyday violence in some parts of the US and the "shock and awe" that occurs when this violence spills over to "normal" communities. This is essentially, and this is very hard to remember, one of the richest countries in the world.

 

I also agree the problems are mostly structural and that tackling "root" issues is difficult. Its not about a "few bad apples", the entire system is currently in a way that creates monsters on all sides - both the police, in their psycho training, and in the general public, with problems of lack of access to health (including mental) care, education, opportunity ect....  No wonder all sides come out swinging. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Cooke (not admin cant help said:

No one seems to give a fuck about the root causes. 

Where do you think the money would be going from the reduction in police spending being called for by the groups you're mocking in this thread?

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Hot Sauce said:

Where do you think the money would be going from the reduction in police spending being called for by the groups you're mocking in this thread?

Purple hair-dye, micro-aggression business cards, and more prisons for CIS-gender males with an over-abundance of privilege. :face:

Edited by Teh_Diplomat
  • dead 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, Cooke (not admin cant help said:

The problem is America is a violent culture.  It's not just police, it's everyday citizens. More people are murdered in Chicago every month than police kill in a decade. No one seems to give a fuck about the root causes. 

That can be fair to a degree. Gun lovers claim guns dont kill, but like we have nearly as many guns in this country as people. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...